Overhead power lines are one of the deadliest hazards on any construction site. A crane boom, a ladder, a length of steel cable: anything that comes within a few feet of a high voltage line can carry enough current to kill. When it happens, the family is left asking a hard question. Who is responsible?
In Virginia, the answer is almost never "only the employer," and often the employer is the one party the family cannot sue at all. A Supreme Court of Virginia decision issued on October 29, 2026 shows how these cases actually play out, and why the type of work being done near the line can change the rules.
The case: a drilling crew, a steel cable, and a line within ten feet
In 2019, Accomack County, on Virginia's Eastern Shore, hired a general contractor to drill new foundations for the guy wires that hold up a county communications tower. The general contractor hired a drilling subcontractor. Kelvin Finck worked for that subcontractor.
An overhead high voltage power line owned by A&N Electric Cooperative ran within ten feet of the drilling site. The line had nothing to do with the tower. While working with the drilling crew, Finck walked a steel cable into the line. He was electrocuted and died several days later.
His estate filed a wrongful death suit in Accomack County Circuit Court against the electric cooperative, the general contractor, the drilling subcontractor that employed him, and an engineering firm the county had hired to evaluate the tower and its guy wire anchors. The estate claimed they all failed to put proper safety measures in place, including the measures required by Virginia's Overhead High Voltage Line Safety Act.
Here is how the case resolved, according to the Supreme Court's opinion:
- The employer was dismissed. The court threw out the claim against Finck's own employer under the exclusive remedy provision of Virginia's workers' compensation law.
- The general contractor settled before trial.
- The electric cooperative went to trial in May 2023 and settled before the jury reached a verdict. Its insurer paid $800,000 to the estate.
The power company then tried to make the contractors pay that $800,000 back, and that fight is what reached the Supreme Court of Virginia in A&N Electric Cooperative v. Dietzel Enterprises, Inc., Record No. 260269 (Va. Oct. 29, 2026).
What Virginia's power line safety law requires
Virginia's Overhead High Voltage Line Safety Act covers work near lines carrying more than 600 volts. Its core rule, in Va. Code § 59.1-408, is that no one may perform work, or require anyone else to perform work, that puts a person, tool, or piece of equipment within 10 feet of a high voltage line unless the danger has been guarded against.
Guarding against it means following § 59.1-410: the person responsible for the work has to notify the line's owner, and the work can go forward only after the two sides agree on safety arrangements. Those can include temporary barriers, shutting off and grounding the line, or moving or raising it.
The Act also shifts money around. Under § 59.1-414(B), a contractor who violates the 10-foot rule and causes an injury or death must repay the power company for the injury and death claims that result, along with its legal fees. That is the provision A&N used to go after the contractors.
The ruling: the Act did not apply to this job
The Supreme Court never reached the repayment question. It held that the Act did not apply to the work at all.
The Act has an exemption, § 59.1-413, for construction and maintenance work on "overhead electrical or communication circuits or conductors and their supporting structures" that belong to rail systems, electric systems, communication systems, or other public or private systems, when the work is done by the system owner's employees or contractors. The power company argued that exemption covers only work on power lines themselves.
The Court disagreed. Reading the plain language, it held that a communications tower is an overhead "communication . . . conductor," its guy wire foundations are "supporting structures," and the drilling crews were contractors working for the county that owned the system. The exemption applied, so the Act's safety and repayment requirements never applied to the contractors. The power line that killed Finck was not part of the tower project, but that did not matter.
The Court acknowledged that the exemption "may have a broad reach," and said whether it should be narrowed is a question for the General Assembly. It also gave examples of work that stays covered: tree trimming near a power line, and ordinary construction on a building or home.
What this means for injured workers and their families
The ruling settled a fight between a power company and contractors, but it carries real lessons for families after a power line injury or death.
The employer is usually off the table, but the case is not over. Virginia's workers' compensation exclusive remedy statute generally bars a worker, or the worker's family, from suing the employer for a workplace injury or death. That is what happened to the claim against Finck's employer. It does not protect everyone else. The Finck family's recovery came from the companies that did not employ him. We explain more about these outside claims in our post on being injured at work by someone else.
Power companies can be held responsible. The utility that owns the line has its own duty of care, and here it chose to pay a substantial settlement rather than let a jury decide. A family should never assume the power company is beyond reach just because their loved one's employer or another contractor made mistakes too.
Whether the safety Act applies depends on what the crew was working on. Families often build these cases around violations of the 10-foot rule. After this decision, if the work was construction or maintenance on a tower, a utility pole, a rail line, or another part of a covered "system," the defense will argue the Act does not apply. That does not end the claim. Ordinary negligence law still applies, and safety duties can come from other sources, including workplace safety regulations. But it changes how the case has to be proved.
There are often several defendants, and they point at each other. The Finck case had four: the utility, the general contractor, the employer, and an engineering firm. Defendants settle at different times and fight among themselves about who pays. How a settlement with one affects the case against the rest is its own issue in Virginia, which we cover in our post on settling with one defendant.
Expect a contributory negligence defense. Virginia is one of the few places where a victim who is even slightly at fault can be barred from recovering anything. In a case where a worker walked a cable into a line, defendants will argue the worker caused his own death. Who set up the job, who knew the line was there, and what training and supervision were provided all matter. Our primer on contributory negligence in D.C., Maryland, and Virginia explains how the rule works.
Who may be responsible after a power line injury or death in Virginia
| Party | Can the family sue? | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| The worker's own employer | Usually no | Workers' compensation is generally the only remedy against the employer (Va. Code § 65.2-307). |
| The power company that owns the line | Often yes | The utility has its own duty of care. In the Finck case, its insurer paid $800,000 to settle. |
| General contractor and other subcontractors | Often yes | They may be responsible for site planning, notice to the utility, and safety measures. |
| Engineers, site owners, and equipment makers | Depends on the facts | Design, inspection, and equipment defects can each create separate claims. |
Act quickly
A Virginia wrongful death claim generally must be filed within two years of the death. Evidence at a job site disappears much faster than that. If a workers' compensation claim has been paid, the employer or its insurer will also have a lien on any recovery from the outside parties, which needs to be handled as part of the case.
If your family member was killed or seriously injured by a power line at work in Virginia, Posey Lebowitz can help you find out who is responsible beyond the employer. Call us at (202) 524-0123 or use our contact form for a free consultation.
This post is general information, not legal advice about your case.
Related articles
- Hit by a Drunk Driver in Virginia? Who Can Be Held Responsible, and Why the Bar Usually Isn't
- Hit by a Car While Working Near a Truck in Virginia? That Truck's Insurance May Cover You
- Hurt by a Company's Former Employee in Virginia? Why the Day They Left the Job Can Decide Your Case
- You Signed a Waiver Before You Got Hurt in Virginia. Can You Still Sue?
